Home > Behaviour & Discipline > 'The Naughty Step' as a Discipline Technique

'The Naughty Step' as a Discipline Technique

By: Beth Morrisey MLIS - Updated: 15 Oct 2013 | comments*Discuss
 
Discipline disciplining Children

The Naughty Step is a discipline technique, in which parents require children who are behaving inappropriately to sit on a certain step for a designated period of time. Many parents favour the Naughty Step, as it is an easy and effective way to teach children that they have been behaving inappropriately. It also helps children to calm down and decide for themselves how to rectify their behaviour.

Using the Naughty Step
In theory, the Naughty Step is a simple device – a designated step on which children are placed when they are misbehaving. In reality the Naughty Step can be the sight of multiple battles of will. Some children love to manipulate the technique and try to outfox their parents by keeping only one foot or one finger on the step, and others are amenable to remaining on the step however they prefer to cry, kick or scream the entire time. Still, other children will realise that they are not physically bound to the step, and will take to vanishing for small periods when they should be sitting as instructed. To counteract these trials, parents should either make sure that the step is in their line of vision or routinely check on the child while (s)he is seated on the step.

The Rationale behind the Naughty Step
The Naughty Step is an effective discipline technique for many reasons. To begin with, it immediately removes a child from the activity or situation which provoked inappropriate behaviour thus, (hopefully) neutralising the behaviour itself. It is also immediate so there is no confusion about why the child is being removed, or which behaviours were inappropriate. Finally, it allows the child the time and space required to calm down and think through their actions. When children are placed on the Naughty Step they should be directed that they can leave when they are ready to discuss the situation. This directs the child’s thoughts towards a resolution of the conflict, and which behaviours would be more appropriate in similar situations in the future.

Adapting the Naughty Step
The Naughty Step is not a technique exclusive to families in large houses, and in fact it can be adapted to almost any living space. For example, a Naughty Rug, Naughty Corner or Naughty Stool works just as well. Almost anything can be used in the place of an actual step, though comfortable chairs and beds should be avoided. The Naughty Step can also be adapted to larger areas as the child grows, so that by the time the child reaches 8 or 9 years of age, there is a designated “calming room” or area where they can be sent as needed. Finally, the Naughty Step can also be used in public – even if it means directing your child to sit quietly on a napkin! Often parents are wary of disciplining children in public, but the Naughty Step is so commonplace these days that other parents are likely to applaud its use whenever and wherever misbehaviour occurs.

Not every parent uses the Naughty Step, but it is a successful discipline technique for many. The Naughty Step removes a child from the source of trouble, it allows the child the time and space to calm down, and it effectively communicates to the child that their behaviour was inappropriate. The Naughty Step can even be adapted to suit any child or location, making it perfectly portable and effective.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
"The naughty step" is no different from using techniques like the "Naughty chair" and "Time-out".These are still forms of punishment.The word, "Naughty" already has a negative connotation and when we send a child to the "naughty" space, we are telling the child that he is naughty.In addition, we are alienating the child from others, from a loved one, at a time where he or she needs emotional assistance or affirmation. How would a young child decide for himself when would be a good time for him to calm down when he is feeling rejected by a parent, a caregiver, or a significant other? Young children display undesired behaviour for a number of reasons. They are young and their brain is not developed sufficiently to remember all the rules of social engagement. They are tired. They are overwhelmed. These are just 3 reasons and there are plenty more. How is putting a child on a "naughty step" because of any of the above reasons going to help the child learn desired behaviour? You got the effects of punishment on children right but you got this part so very wrong.
Den - 15-Oct-13 @ 11:02 AM
It would be useful to have the practicalities of the naughty step included in the article. Or rather not just have the theory of it. For example, in which cases do you use it? Is it the last resort for bad/unfavourable behaviour? Is it not punishment? Isn't one depriving their child of freedom for some time (1 minute/child's year)? Also what do you do with wild tantrums? When the child has no control over logic and physically WILLNOT stay on the step? do you forcefully make him stay? Or are you implying that all misbehaviour is premeditaed and can be stopped at a whim? Please make your article more complete and userfriendly for the lay reader. If a parent is reading this then more than likely they are looking for practical answers. My humble opinion no more
Antonia - 14-Oct-13 @ 3:52 AM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • emma
    Re: B.F. Skinner's Behavioural Theory
    nyc one wat is the difference between response behavior and instrumental behavior
    27 February 2017
  • Lucy78
    Re: Child Temper Tantrums
    @Kitty - that's a good idea. Most children want to get their point across when and where they possibly can :) A bit of displacement…
    13 February 2017
  • Kitty
    Re: Child Temper Tantrums
    I usually try to get to the point on What is the cause of the fuss. Either than that I normally ask the child to calm down explain for…
    12 February 2017
  • Joannas
    Re: The 'Terrible Twos'
    I care for a 20 month old that hits his head on the floor or on furniture when he has a temper tantrum. Is there a strategy I can use to help…
    22 January 2017
  • KidsDevelopment
    Re: John Bowlby's Attachment Theory
    Rosie - Your Question:Thanks a lot for this very well researched and educative workOur Response:
    3 January 2017
  • Rosie
    Re: John Bowlby's Attachment Theory
    Thanks a lot for this very well researched and educative work
    2 January 2017
  • Juniper
    Re: The Effects of Punishment on Children
    I think negative punish is not good but we all use them may be unintentionally
    21 December 2016
  • Ceci
    Re: The 'Terrible Twos'
    One particular on fb and child and mother were at the mall ready to check there items standing next to mom was a screaming child wanting a toy…
    1 October 2016
  • Ceci
    Re: Child Temper Tantrums
    Iam preschool teachers aid and I find that in one child In my room he has a tantrum drop off in the mornings also when a teacher leaves the…
    1 October 2016
  • Kayla ross
    Re: Babies' Awareness of Other People
    My child is 1 years old. Now I will have to go away for 6 to 12 months here soon. Will my child for get me
    16 September 2016
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the KidsDevelopment website. Please read our Disclaimer.